Skip to main content

Table 1 Conceptualization of the term ‘Institutionalization’

From: Understanding psychiatric institutionalization: a conceptual review

Author(s), year

Country

Bricks & mortar

Policy & legal frameworks

Clinical responsibility & paternalism

Patients’ adaptive behavior to care

1960s

Pine & Levinson, 1961 [75]

U.S.A

   

X

Wing & Brown, 1961 [67]

U.K

X

  

X

Wing 1962 [63]

U.K

   

X

Barton, 1966 [69]

U.S.A

   

X

Gruenberg 1967 [73]

U.S.A

   

X

Karmel, 1969 [65]

U.S.A

   

X

1970s

Gomia et al. 1970 [30]

U.S.A

 

X

X

X

Wing & Brown, 1970 [64]

U.K

X

  

X

Moos, 1972 [23]

U.S.A

X

 

X

 

Ochberg et al., 1972 [68]

U.S.A

   

X

Moos, 1973 [24]

U.S.A

X

 

X

 

Rosenhan, 1973 [71]

U.S.A

   

X

1980s

Johnstone, Owens et al. 1981 [74]

U.K

   

X

Liberakis, 1981 [70]

Canada

X

  

X

Goldney, Bowes et al., 1985

Australia

  

X

 

Wasow, 1986 [48]

U.S.A

  

X

 

Talbott & Glick, 1986 [46]

U.S.A

  

X

 

1990s

Myers, Leahy et al., 1990

U.K

 

X

X

 

Wing, 1990 [49]

U.K

X

 

X

 

Curson, et al. 1992 [66]

U.K

   

X

Abrahamson, 1993

U.K

   

X

Taj and Sheehan, 1994 [25]

Ireland

X

 

X

 

Prior, 1995 [51]

U.K

  

X

 

Eklund & Hansson, 1997 [47]

Sweden

  

X

 

Breeze, 1998

Sweden

  

X

 

Ford, et al. 1998 [72]

U.K

   

X

Lutzen, 1998 [61]

Sweden

  

X

 

Owen, Tarantello, et al. 1998 [52]

Australia

 

X

X

 

McCubbin & Cohen, 1999 [59]

UK

  

X

 

Nijman, a Compo et al., 1999 [53]

The Netherlands

  

X

 

2000s- Present

Boardman & Hodgson, 2000 [19]

U.K

X

   

Quirk & Lelliott, 2001 [56]

U.K

  

X

 

Bowers, Crowhurst et al., 2002 [34]

U.K

 

X

  

Dvoski et al., 2002 [22]

U.S.A

  

X

 

Lewis, 2002 [36]

U.K

 

X

  

Zinkler & Priebe, 2002 [39]

U.K

 

X

  

O’Brien & Cole, 2003 [50]

Australia

X

 

X

 

Salize &Dressing, 2004 [40]

Germany

 

X

  

Priebe, 2004 [18]

U.K

  

X

 

Rittmannsberger et al., 2004 [31]

Europe

  

X

 

Canvin, Bartlett & Pinfold, 2005 [55]

U.K

  

X

 

Karlin & Zeiss, 2006 [28]

U.S.A

X

   

Katsakou & Priebe, 2006 [41]

U.K

 

X

  

Killaspy, 2006 [54]

U.K

  

X

 

Quirk, Lelliott & Seale, 2006 [20]

U.K

X

X

X

 

De Girolamo et al., 2007

Italy

 

X

X

 

Haglund et al., 2007 [33]

Sweden

 

X

  

McNown Johnson & Rhodes, 2007 [38]

U.S.A

X

X

X

 

Sine, 2008 [26]

U.S.A

X

   

Johnson, Gilburt et al. 2009 [21]

U.K

X

 

X

 

van der Merwe et al. 2009 [32]

U.K

 

X

X

X

Priebe, Katsakou et al., 2009 [58]

U.K

 

X

X

 

Coldefy & Curtis, 2010 [29]

France

X

   

Katsakou, Bowers et al., 2010 [42]

U.K

 

X

  

Lang et al., 2010 [35]

Germany

 

X

  

Molodynski, Rugkåsa & Burns, 2010 [44]

U.K

 

X

 

X

Priebe, Katsakou et al., 2010 [43]

U.K

 

X

  

Sheehan & Burns, 2011 [57]

U.K

 

X

X

 

Lay, Nordt & Roessler,2011 [60]

Switzerland

  

X

 

Georgieva, Mulder & Wierdsma, 2012 [37]

The Netherlands

 

X

  

Reumschussel-Wienert & Crefeld, 2012 [45]

Germany

 

X

 Â