From: Effects of dog-assisted therapy in adults with dementia: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Outcomes | Anticipated absolute effects* (95% CI) | Relative effect (95% CI) | ā of participants and studies (I: intervention, C: control) | Certainty of the evidence (GRADE) | Comments |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Risk with Animal-assisted therapy | |||||
Activities of daily living | SMD 0.16 SD more (0.80 lower to 1.12 more) | ā | I 31 C 30 (2 RCTs) | āØāÆāÆāÆ VERY LOWa,b,c | We are uncertain about the effect of DAT on activities of daily living. |
Depression | SMD 0.48 SD lower (1.93 lower to 0.98 higher) | ā | I 80 C 82 (4 RCTs) | āØāÆāÆāÆ VERY LOWa,b,c,d | We are uncertain about the effect of DAT on depression. |
Agitation | SMD 1.12 SD lower (2.67 lower to 0.43 higher) | ā | I 86 C 87 (3 RCTs) | āØāÆāÆāÆ VERY LOWa,b,c | We are uncertain about the effect of DAT on agitation. |
Quality of life | SMD 0.16 SD higher (0.41 lower to 0.73 higher) | ā | I 76 C 75 (3 RCTs) | āØāÆāÆāÆ VERY LOWb,c,e | We are uncertain about the effect of DAT on quality of life. |
Cognitive impairment | SMD 0.52 SD lower (1.33 lower to 0.30 higher) | I 12 C 12 (1 RCT) | āØāÆāÆāÆ VERY LOWa,c | We are uncertain about the effect of DAT on cognitive impairment. | |
Apathy | SMD 2.10 SD higher (1.29 higher to 2.91 higher) | I 19 C 18 (1 RCT) | āØāÆāÆāÆ VERY LOWa,c | We are uncertain about the effect of DAT on apathy. |