Skip to main content

Table 4 PHQ-9 and WHODAS outcomes over time and across cohort groups

From: Evaluation of a collaborative care model for integrated primary care of common mental disorders comorbid with chronic conditions in South Africa

 

Control group

Treatment group

adjusted β or RR d (95%CI)

p

N

Mean score (SD) or N (%)

Adjusted mean change (95%CI) from baseline

N

Mean score (SD) or N (%)

Adjusted mean change (95%CI) from baseline

Midline (3 months)a

Response on PHQ-9 b

209

49 (23.4%)

–

125

69 (55.2%)

–

2.10 (1.53 to 2.88)

< 0.001

Remission on PHQ-9 c

209

25 (12.0%)

–

125

40 (32.0%)

–

2.78 (1.70 to 4.54)

< 0.001

PHQ-9 score

209

9.6 (4.66)

-2.63 (− 3.34 to − 1.92)

125

8.0 (6.16)

−5.05 (− 6.02 to − 4.08)

− 2.42 (− 3.49 to − 1.34)

< 0.001

WHODAS score

209

34.7 (21.14)

− 4.65 (−8.02 to − 1.28)

125

23.6 (20.99)

− 11.11 (− 15.18 to − 7.05)

− 6.46 (− 11.37 to − 1.55)

0.010

Endline (12 months)a

Response on PHQ-9 b

195

60 (30.8%)

–

119

57 (47.9%)

–

1.52 (1.13 to 2.05)

0.006

Remission on PHQ-9 c

195

33 (16.9%)

–

119

32 (26.9%)

–

1.72 (1.11 to 2.68)

0.016

PHQ-9 score

195

9.0 (4.89)

−3.10 (− 3.83 to − 2.37)

119

7.9 (5.17)

−5.07 (− 6.05 to − 4.09)

−1.97 (− 3.04 to − 0.90)

< 0.001

WHODAS score

195

31.3 (22.39)

−7.20 (− 10.68 to − 3.73)

119

28.4 (21.64)

−8.00 (− 12.02 to − 3.99)

−0.80 (− 5.68 to 4.07)

0.746

  1. a Comparison group is the reference group; b defined as at least 50% reduction in score at follow-up compared to baseline; c defined as PHQ-9 < 5 at follow-up; d RR = Risk ratio