Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of the differences between the health care contracts

From: Depression treatment in Germany – using claims data to compare a collaborative mental health care program to the general practitioner program and usual care in terms of guideline adherence and need-oriented access to psychotherapy

 

Usual care

General practitioner program

Specialists’ program

Gatekeeping

none (i.e. free choice between all health care providers that are licensed to bill their services to a SHI)

commitment to first seek help from one particular GP enrolled in the program (exception: e.g. emergencies, gynecologist)

free choice between specialists if patients are referred by the GP

commitment to first seek help from one particular GP enrolled in the program (exception: e.g. emergencies, gynecologist)

free choice between participating specialists if patients are referred by the GP

Differences in the organization and payment of psychotherapy

The first 5 preparatory sessions are compensated to a lesser extent (64 €) when compared to regular sessions (84 €)

• review process for approval of long-term psychotherapy

• more highly frequented therapy possible for people with severe mental disorders (max. 80 h for behavioral therapy, max. 100 for psychodynamic therapy and max. 300 for analytic therapy)

• waiting time until initial assessment on average approx.. 11,4 weeks in BW [43]

The first 5 preparatory sessions are compensated to a lesser extent (64 €) when compared to regular sessions (84 €)

review process for approval of long-term psychotherapy

more highly frequented therapy possible for people with severe mental disorders (max. 80 h for behavioral therapy, max. 100 for psychodynamic therapy and max. 300 for analytic therapy)

waiting time until initial assessment on average approx.. 11,4 weeks in BW [43]

stepped payment scheme (105 € for urgent cases for max 10 sessions, 90€ for the following max 20 sessions, 84.5€ for the following sessions)

higher payment for group psychotherapy

after 60 h of therapy only therapy with a low frequency (max. 6 times per quarter) is billable (exception: personality disorders or if the diagnosis changes), application for an extension (e.g. to prevent relapse) is possible

start of psychotherapy within 4 weeks after established diagnosis, for acute cases: initial session within 3 days; start of psychotherapy within 7 days after established diagnosis

Differences in the organization and payment of psychiatry

  

Psychiatry: additional supplement (e.g. for counseling, prescription of discounted medication), limit of waiting time to 30 min, for acute cases: first appointment within the same day

Differences in the organization and payment of neurology

  

Neurology: additional supplements (e.g. Multiple Sclerosis counselling: 6 units of 20 min per year, provision of assistants), limit of waiting time up to 30 min, for acute cases: first doctor’s appointment within the same day

  1. AOK is a large statutory health insurance company in Germany, BW Baden-Württemberg (region in southwest Germany), GP general practitioner, PNP psychiatrist neurologist psychotherapist contract, All actual € values refer to the costs in the first Quarter of 2015