Author, year | NIBS technique | Psychosocial intervention | Target population | Sample size (I/C) | Age Mean (SD) | Gender (F/M) | Duration Mean (SD) | Depressive outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Brunoni et al., 2014 [27] | Anodal tDCS | Cognitive control therapy | Major depressive disorder (MDD) | 37(20/17) | IG: 46.1(10.4) CG: 41.5(10.6) | IG: 7/13 CG: 4/13 | IG: 17.4(15.8) M CG: 9.2(9.2) M | HDRS-21 BDI |
Guinot et al., 2021 [28] | HF-rTMS | Exercise training | Fibromyalgia (FM) | 39(20/19) | IG: 46.5(10.4) CG: 42.8(8.8) | IG: 18/0 CG: 15/4 | IG: 11.2(10.9) Y CG: 9.2(9.6) Y | BDI |
Khayyer et al., 2018 [29] | Anodal tDCS | Positive psychotherapy | MDD | 9(3/3/3) | 45 | N/A | N/A | HDRS |
Lagueux et al., 2018 [30] | Anodal tDCS | Graded motor imagery | Complex regional pain syndrome | 22(11/11) | IG: 41(9) CG: 53(10) | IG: 8/3 CG: 6/5 | IG: 36(26) M CG: 37(26) M | BDI-II |
Lee and Kim, 2018 [31] | LF-rTMS | Neurodevelopmental therapy | Traumatic brain injury | 13(7/6) | IG: 42.42(11.32) CG: 41.33(11.02) | IG: 2/5 CG: 2/4 | IG: 3.85(1.67) M CG: 3.88(1.94) M | MADRS |
Li et al., 2021 [32] | HF-rTMS | Occupational therapy | Morphine dependence | 100(50/50) | IG: 33.8 (7.5) CG: 36.2 (8.0) | IG: 14/36 CG: 11/39 | IG: 6.8(3.6) Y CG: 7.1(3.3) Y | SDS |
Manenti et al., 2016 [33] | Anodal tDCS | Physical therapy | Parkinson | 20(10/10) | IG: 69.0 (9.1) CG: 69.1 (5.6) | IG: 6/4 CG: 3/7 | IG: 7.1(3.6) Y CG: 7.8(4.2) Y | BDI-II |
Manenti et al., 2018 [34] | Anodal tDCS | Computerized cognitive training | Parkinson | 22(11/11) | IG: 65.5(6.4) CG: 63.8(7.1) | IG: 6/5 CG: 4/7 | IG: 6.2(3.9) Y CG: 7.6(3.4) Y | BDI-II |
Martin et al., 2019 [35] | Anodal tDCS | Cognitive training | Mild cognitive impairment | 68(33/35) | IG: 71.8(6.39) CG: 71.6(6.35) | IG: 20/13 CG: 25/10 | N/A | MADRS |
Mendonca et al., 2016 [36] | Anodal tDCS | Aerobic exercise | FM | 45(15/15/15) | IG: 44.5(14) CG1: 48.0(11.8) CG2: 49.9(10.6) | IG: 14/1 CG1: 15/0 CG2: 15/0 | IG: 140.6(72.2) M CG1:149.3(111.1) M CG2: 126.6(100.2) M | BDI |
Nasiri et al., 2020 [37] | Anodal tDCS | Unified protocol treatment | Generalized anxiety disorder and comorbid depression | 47 (15/15/17) | IG: 20.23(2.89) CG1: 21.53(3.56) CG2: 20.53(2.53) | IG: 10/3 CG1: 11/4 CG2: 11/4 | N/A | BDI-II |
Nord et al., 2019 [38] | Anodal tDCS | Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) | MDD | 39(20/19) | IG: 35.60(12.91) CG: 31.05(8.17) | IG:9/11 CG: 11/8 | N/A | BDI HAM-D |
Riberto et al., 2011 [39] | Anodal tDCS | Multidisciplinary rehabilitation program | FM | 23(11/12) | IG: 58.3(12.1) CG: 52.4(11.5) | N/A | IG: 141.63 (184.11) M CG1: 84.11 (102.09) M CG2: 37.33 (39.12) M | BDI HDRS |
Segrave et al., 2014 [40] | Anodal tDCS | Cognitive control training | MDD | 27(9/9/9) | IG: 42.6(18.32) CG1: 45.0(10.15) CG2: 33.8(12.96) | IG: 2/7 CG1: 4/5 CG2: 4/5 | N/A | MADRS BDI-II |
Sharma et al., 2020 [41] | LF-rTMS | Conventional physical therapy | Ischemic stroke | 100(50/50) | IG: 54.85(13.39) CG: 52.89(14.95) | IG: 14/33 CG: 15/34 | N/A | HAM-D |
Van Noppen et al., 2020 [42] | Anodal tDCS | Behavioral therapy | Burnout | 16(8/8) | IG: 42.5(5.5) CG: 47.4(5.3) | Â | N/A IG: 31.31(8.17) M CG: 10(9.63) M | BDI |
Vanderhasselt et al., 2015 [43] | Anodal tDCS | Neurocognitive training | MDD | 33(19/14) | IG: 42.26(10.67) CG: 41.00(11.54) | IG: 13/6 CG: 11/3 | NA | HAM-D BDI-II |