Skip to main content

Table 3 Mean score and standard deviation for HSCL-25 at baseline and follow-up, according to Axis II disorders. Paired t-test and independent t-test.

From: Axis I and II disorders as long-term predictors of mental distress: a six-year prospective follow-up of substance-dependent patients

 

T1

T2

  

Axis II disorders

Mean

SD

Mean

SD

Pa

Pb

Any Axis II disorder

      

Yes (98)

2.22

0.60

2.10

0.65

0.090

0.008

No (36)

1.76

0.51

1.79

0.52

0.733

 

Paranoid

      

Yes (n = 6)

2.40

0.56

2.55

0.31

0.638

0.035

No (n = 128)

2.08

0.61

1.99

0.63

0.139

 

Schizoid

      

Yes (n = 23)

2.45

0.65

2.25

0.54

0.224

0.049

No (n = 111)

2.02

0.58

1.97

0.64

0.397

 

Schizotyp

      

Yes (n = 17)

2.66

0.58

2.34

0.62

0.088

0.025

No (n = 117)

2.01

0.57

1.97

0.62

0.496

 

Antisocial

      

Yes (n = 43)

2.17

0.60

2.14

0.65

0.728

0.136

No (n = 91)

2.06

0.61

1.96

0.62

0.161

 

Borderline

      

Yes (n = 43)

2.45

0.58

2.26

0.61

0.110

0.002

No (n = 91)

1.92

0.55

1.90

0.62

0.699

 

Histrionic

      

Yes (n = 17)

2.14

0.61

2.04

0.83

0.533

0.849

No (n = 117)

2.09

0.61

2.01

0.60

0.238

 

Narcissistic

      

Yes (n = 19)

2.14

0.60

2.21

0.76

0.653

0.161

No (n = 115)

2.08

0.61

1.99

0.61

0.117

 

Avoidant

      

Yes (n = 52)

2.45

0.57

2.28

0.58

0.098

< 0.001

No (n = 82)

1.87

0.52

1.85

0.61

0.802

 

Dependent

      

Yes (n = 24)

2.43

0.62

2.19

0.69

0.051

0.129

No (n = 110)

2.02

0.58

1.98

0.62

0.529

 

Compulsive

      

Yes (n = 8)

2.34

0.86

2.19

0.77

0.544

0.420

No (n = 126)

2.08

0.59

2.01

0.63

0.226

 

Passive-aggressive

      

Yes (n = 54)

2.32

0.57

2.28

0.60

0.594

< 0.001

No (n = 80)

1.94

0.59

1.84

0.60

0.207

 

Self-defeating

      

Yes (n = 36)

2.59

0.59

2.33

0.62

0.045

< 0.001

No (n = 98)

1.91

0.51

1.90

0.60

0.886

 

Aggressive-sadistic

      

Yes (n = 33)

2.22

0.54

2.23

0.59

0.291

0.029

No (n = 101)

2.05

0.62

1.95

0.64

0.558

 

Number of Axis II disorders

      

0 (n = 36)

1.76

0.51

1.79

0.52

0.733

< 0.001c

1–3 (n = 47)

1.99

0.52

1.82

0.64

0.083

 

4 + (n = 51)

2.43

0.59

2.36

0.56

0.485

 
  1. aP value on paired t-test.
  2. bP value on independent t-test HSCL-25 T2
  3. cOne-way ANOVA: number of Axis II disorders, df = 9, F = 4.0, P < 0.001.