Skip to main content

Table 1 Demographic characteristics and clinical outcome variables of randomized participants

From: A randomized controlled trial on the comparative effectiveness of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and health qigong-based cognitive therapy among Chinese people with depression and anxiety disorders

 

MBCT

(n = 62)

HQCT

(n = 62)

WC

(n = 63)

   

%

%

%

   

Gender

 Male

29.0

32.3

27.0

   

 Female

71.0

67.7

73.0

   

Education

 Primary

17.7

14.5

17.5

   

 Secondary

58.1

48.4

58.7

   

 Tertiary

24.2

37.1

23.8

   
    

MBCT vs. WC

HQCT vs. WC

MBCT vs. HQCT

 

Χ (SD)

Χ (SD)

Χ (SD)

ES

ES

ES

Age

51.6 (9.5)

50.7 (10.6)

49.2 (12.4)

   

DASS-21 (T0)

33.4 (12.2)

34.8 (12.7)

33.1 (14.3)

   

DASS-21 (T1)

28.8 (11.7)

27.2 (11.6)

32.1 (14.2)

−0.27a

−0.49a

0.24a

DASS-21 (T2)

27.2 (11.4)

26.2 (10.8)

31.3 (13.0)

−0.33b

−0.5b

0.19b

SF12_Phy (T0)

12.6 (2.4)

12.6 (2.6)

12.7 (2.7)

   

SF12_Phy (T1)

12.9 (2.5)

13.2 (2.7)

12.4 (2.6)

0.23a

0.34a

−0.12a

SF12_Phy (T2)

12.9 (2.4)

13.9 (2.5)

12.3 (2.6)

0.27b

0.64b

−0.40b

SF12_Men (T0)

15.9 (3.5)

15.5 (3.5)

15.4 (3.2)

   

SF12_Men (T1)

17.3 (3.5)

16.3 (3.3)

15.7 (3.2)

0.33a

0.15a

0.17a

SF12_Men (T2)

17.7 (3.5)

16.5 (3.2)

15.3 (3.1)

0.56b

0.33b

0.23b

CPSS (T0)

20.2 (6.4)

22.9 (6.4)

23.0 (5.6)

   

CPSS (T1)

18.0 (6.2)

22.7 (6.5)

23.1 (5.3)

−0.38a

−0.05a

0.21a

CPSS (T2)

17.9 (6.6)

20.6 (6.2)

22.7 (5.5)

−0.33b

−0.33b

0.00b

PSQI (T0)

10.9 (4.1)

10.6 (3.8)

11.1 (4.6)

   

PSQI (T1)

10.0 (3.4)

9.8 (3.3)

11.3 (5.0)

−0.25a

−0.24a

−0.03a

PSQI (T2)

9.9 (3.5)

9.8 (3.5)

11.5 (4.7)

−0.32b

−0.28b

− 0.05b

GSE (T0)

21.0 (6.0)

22.3 (6.1)

21.8 (6.5)

   

GSE (T1)

21.6 (6.4)

23.5 (5.4)

21.7 (5.8)

0.11a

0.21a

−0.10a

GSE (T2)

21.6 (6.3)

23.7 (5.9)

21.5 (6.5)

0.14b

0.27b

−0.13b

  1. All comparisons of demographic data (between-group ANOVA or X2 tests) are nonsignificant, p > .05; aComparison between T0 and T1; bComparison between T0 and T2
  2. MBCT Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, HQCT Health qigong based cognitive therapy, WC Waitlist control, DASS-21 21-item Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale, SF12 Short-form 12, Phy Physical health status, Men Mental health status, CPSS Chinese Perceived Stress Scale, PSQI Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, GSE General Self-efficacy Scale