Table 2 Quality assessment of guidelines
Guideline | Domain1: Scope and purpose | Domain2: Stakeholder involvement | Domain 3: Rigour of development | Domain 4: Clarity of presentation | Domain 5: Applicability | Domain 6: Editorial independence | Overall quality | Recommendation of use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NICE 2011 [37] | 100.00% | 84.00% | 73.00% | 95.00% | 67.00% | 83.00% | 7 | Recommended |
NICE 2014 [55] | 100.00% | 84.00% | 73.00% | 95.00% | 67.00% | 83.00% | 7 | Recommended |
RANZCP 2016 [50] | 83.00% | 72.00% | 35.00% | 83.00% | 33.00% | 42.00% | 4 | Recommended with modification |
BAP 2012 [40] | 83.00% | 61.00% | 54.00% | 83.00% | 42.00% | 42.00% | 5 | Recommended with modification |
WFSBP 2017 [41] | 83.00% | 50.00% | 60.00% | 67.00% | 25.00% | 42.00% | 4 | Recommended with modification |
gov.uk 2017 [42] | 94.00% | 67.00% | 60.00% | 72.00% | 33.00% | 33.00% | 7 | Recommended |
DGPPN and DG-Sucht 2017 [43] | 83.00% | 56.00% | 63.00% | 78.00% | 33.00% | 50.00% | 4 | Recommended with modification |
NICE 2011 [44] | 100.00% | 84.00% | 73.00% | 95.00% | 67.00% | 83.00% | 7 | Recommended |
ASAM 2015 [46] | 67.00% | 72.00% | 52.00% | 83.00% | 38.00% | 58.00% | 5 | Recommended with modification |
APA 2018 [45] | 89.00% | 56.00% | 65.00% | 83.00% | 42.00% | 75.00% | 6 | Recommended |
Singapore MOH 2011 [54] | 67.00% | 56.00% | 25.00% | 89.00% | 38.00% | 17.00% | 3 | Not recommended |
VA/DoD 2010 [53] | 83.00% | 56.00% | 58.00% | 83.00% | 38.00% | 17.00% | 4 | Recommended with modification |
CANMAT & ISBD 2018 [57] | 67.00% | 61.00% | 31.00% | 61.00% | 29.00% | 42.00% | 3 | Not recommended |
SIGN 2013 [47] | 94.00% | 83.00% | 71.00% | 95.00% | 50.00% | 50.00% | 7 | Recommended |
WFSBP 2015 [49] | 83.00% | 50.00% | 60.00% | 67.00% | 25.00% | 42.00% | 4 | Recommended with modification |
NICE 2016Â [38] | 100.00% | 84.00% | 73.00% | 95.00% | 67.00% | 83.00% | 7 | Recommended |
NICE 2014 [48] | 100.00% | 84.00% | 73.00% | 95.00% | 67.00% | 83.00% | 7 | Recommended |
BAP 2019 [51] | 83.00% | 61.00% | 54.00% | 83.00% | 33.00% | 42.00% | 5 | Recommended with modification |
BAP 2016 [56] | 83.00% | 61.00% | 54.00% | 83.00% | 33.00% | 42.00% | 5 | Recommended with modification |
APA 2020 [52] | 89.00% | 56.00% | 65.00% | 83.00% | 42.00% | 75.00% | 6 | Recommended |
Australian government 2016 [39] | 78.00% | 56.00% | 21.00% | 89.00% | 38.00% | 25.00% | 3 | Not recommended |