Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparison with the literature from previous research (before COVID)

From: Psychiatric and non-psychiatric population vulnerabilities in time of a crisis: the unsuspected aggression factor

Scale

Results from the present research

Differences

Literature scores

N

Cohen’s d

SBQ-R

Clinical (Gp3)

 < 

Clinical

69

1.01

Non clinical (Gp1)

 > 

Non Clinical

120

.09

HADS-A

Clinical (Gp3) + 

 > 

Clinical + 

491

.03

Non clinical (Gp1) + 

 > 

Non Clinical

1792

.05

HADS-D

Clinical (Gp3)

 < 

Clinical + 

491

.46

Non clinical (Gp1)

 > 

Non Clinical

1792

.40

Negative Urgency

Clinical (Gp3) + 

 < 

Clinical + 

81

.1

Non clinical (Gp1) + 

 > 

Non Clinical

650

.74

Positive Urgency

Clinical (Gp3) + 

 < 

Clinical + 

268

.4

Non clinical (Gp1) + 

 > 

Non Clinical

650

.27

Lack of Premeditation

Clinical (Gp3) + 

 < 

Clinical + 

268

.34

Non clinical (Gp1) + 

 > 

Non Clinical

650

.21

Lack of Perseverance

Clinical (Gp3)

 < 

Clinical + 

268

.16

Non clinical (Gp1)

 < 

Non Clinical

650

.09

Sensation Seeking

Clinical (Gp3)

 < 

Clinical + 

81

.30

Non clinical (Gp1)

 > 

Non Clinical

650

.25

Hopelesness

Clinical (Gp3) + 

 < 

Clinical + 

340

.20

Non clinical (Gp1) + 

 > 

Non Clinical

100

.02

AQ12

Clinical (Gp1) + 

 < 

Clinical + 

107

.26

Non Clinical (Gp3)

 > 

Non Clinical

101

.94

  1. Note: < or >  = cohen’s d higher than .25; < or >  = cohen’s d lower then. 25, Non clinical sample: n = 201, Clinical sample: n = 68, AQ12 scores extracted from Vitoratou et al. [50], Hopelessness scale scores extracted from Szabó et al. [51], UPPS scores extracted from Martin et al. [52]; Hads scores extracted from Crawford et al. [53] and Spinhoven et al. [54]; Sbqr scores extracted from Osman et al. [42] and Au et al. [55]; + : above pathological sthresolds