Skip to main content

Table 1 Sociodemographic, detention-related and clinical variables in the present series

From: Women in acute forensic psychiatric care: comparison of clinical, sociodemographic, and detention-related characteristics in pretrial detention, sentence execution, and court-ordered treatment

 

Type of detention

p

BH

 

Pre-trial

 

Sentence

 

COT

 

Total

  

N

54 (39.7%)

 

66 (48.5%)

 

16 (11.8%)

 

136 (100.0%)

  

Age

38.9 [16.2]

 

36.3 [16.2]

 

35.6 [10.4]

 

36.6 [15.2]

0.311

 

Nationality

       

0.173

 

EU

22 (40.7%)

 

19 (28.8%)

 

4 (25.0%)

 

45 (33.1%)

  

Extra-EU

12 (22.2%)

 

28 (42.4%)

 

7 (43.8%)

 

47 (34.6%)

  

Swiss

20 (37.0%)

 

19 (28.8%)

 

5 (31.2%)

 

44 (32.4%)

  

Marital status

       

0.560

 

Single

28 (51.9%)

 

29 (43.9%)

 

7 (43.8%)

 

64 (47.1%)

  

Separed-divorced-widowed

17 (31.5%)

 

26 (39.4%)

 

4 (25.0%)

 

47 (34.6%)

  

Married

9 (16.7%)

 

11 (16.7%)

 

5 (31.2%)

 

25 (18.4%)

  

Children

29 (53.7%)

 

38 (57.6%)

 

7 (43.8%)

 

74 (54.4%)

0.612

 

Education

       

0.489

 

Drop-out

16 (29.6%)

 

25 (37.9%)

 

6 (37.5%)

 

47 (34.6%)

  

Obligatory schooling

17 (31.5%)

 

21 (31.8%)

 

5 (31.2%)

 

43 (31.6%)

  

Apprenticeship

13 (24.1%)

 

17 (25.8%)

 

5 (31.2%)

 

35 (25.7%)

  

High school, university

8 (14.8%)

 

3 (4.5%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

11 (8.1%)

  

Language (French)

46 (85.2%)

 

58 (87.9%)

 

15 (93.8%)

 

119 (87.5%)

0.762

 

Social support

46 (85.2%)

 

62 (93.9%)

 

14 (87.5%)

 

122 (89.7%)

0.241

 

Employment before conviction

       

0.170

 

Invalidity pension

6 (11.1%)

 

15 (22.7%)

 

3 (18.8%)

 

24 (17.6%)

  

Students

0 (0.0%)

 

1 (1.5%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

1 (0.7%)

  

None

15 (27.8%)

 

10 (15.2%)

 

6 (37.5%)

 

31 (22.8%)

  

Yes

33 (61.1%)

 

40 (60.6%)

 

7 (43.8%)

 

80 (58.8%)

  

Type of offenses

       

0.096

 

Unpaid fine

3 (5.6%)

 

4 (6.2%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

7 (5.2%)

  

Property violation

6 (11.1%)

 

11 (16.9%)

 

1 (6.2%)

 

18 (13.3%)

  

Fraud

2 (3.7%)

 

7 (10.8%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

9 (6.7%)

  

Arson

2 (3.7%)

 

2 (3.1%)

 

2 (12.5%)

 

6 (4.4%)

  

Physical violence

13 (24.1%)

 

20 (30.8%)

 

8 (50.0%)

 

41 (30.4%)

  

Drug trafficking

8 (14.8%)

 

12 (18.5%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

20 (14.8%)

  

Other

16 (29.6%)

 

6 (9.2%)

 

5 (31.2%)

 

27 (20.0%)

  

Honor and privacy

2 (3.7%)

 

2 (3.1%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

4 (3.0%)

  

Stalking

2 (3.7%)

 

1 (1.5%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

3 (2.2%)

  

Number of stays

a

  

b

 

a,b

 

0.004

*

1

38 (70.4%)

 

49 (74.2%)

 

6 (37.5%)

 

93 (68.4%)

  

2–10

16 (29.6%)

 

16 (24.2%)

 

7 (43.8%)

 

39 (28.7%)

  

> 10

0 (0.0%)

 

1 (1.5%)

 

3 (18.8%)

 

4 (2.9%)

  

Length of stay

18.0 [32.0]

 

21.5 [31.0]

 

14.0 [22.0]

 

18.5 [30.5]

0.544

 

Psychiatric history

c

  

d

 

c,d

 

< 0.001

*

None

7 (13.0%)

 

20 (30.3%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

27 (19.9%)

  

Outpatient

12 (22.2%)

 

22 (33.3%)

 

1

(6.2%)

 

35 (25.7%)

  

Inpatient

35 (64.8%)

 

24 (36.4%)

 

15 (93.8%)

 

74 (54.4%)

  

Main diagnosis (ICD-10)

 

e

f

  

e,f

 

0.004

*

Adjustment disorder

12 (22.2%)

 

7 (10.6%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

19 (14.0%)

  

Affective disorders (bipolar and depressive)

12 (22.2%)

 

23 (34.8%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

35 (25.7%)

  

Personality disorders

14 (25.9%)

 

20 (30.3%)

 

6 (37.5%)

 

40 (29.4%)

  

Psychotic disorders

13 (24.1%)

 

14 (21.2%)

 

10 (62.5%)

 

37 (27.2%)

  

Other

3 (5.6%)

 

2 (3.0%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

5 (3.7%)

  

Substance use disorders

16 (29.6%)

 

20 (30.3%)

 

5 (31.2%)

 

41 (30.1%)

1.000

 

Personality

       

0.576

 

None

28 (51.9%)

 

29 (43.9%)

 

7 (43.8%)

 

64 (47.1%)

  

Not otherwise specified

4 (7.4%)

 

7 (10.6%)

 

1 (6.2%)

 

12 (8.8%)

  

Borderline

20 (37.0%)

 

25 (37.9%)

 

6 (37.5%)

 

51 (37.5%)

  

Cluster A

2 (3.7%)

 

2 (3.0%)

 

0 (0.0%)

 

4 (2.9%)

  

Narcissistic/Histrionic

0 (0.0%)

 

3 (4.5%)

 

2 (12.5%)

 

5 (3.7%)

  

Suicidal issues

       

0.136

 

No

26 (48.1%)

 

28 (42.4%)

 

10 (62.5%)

 

64 (47.1%)

  

Suicidal attempt

9 (16.7%)

 

17 (25.8%)

 

5 (31.2%)

 

31 (22.8%)

  

Suicidal thoughts

19 (35.2%)

 

21 (31.8%)

 

1 (6.2%)

 

41 (30.1%)

  
  1. BH Threshold: p = 0.00882
  2. Kruskal Wallis for continuous variables
  3. a: PTD vs COT; p = 0.005
  4. b: SE vs COT; p=0.011
  5. Fisher's exact test for factor variables
  6. c and d: PTD vs COT; p = 0.001
  7. e: PTD vs COT p = 0.007
  8. f: SE vs COT p = 0.002