The role of oxytocin receptor gene (OXTR) DNA methylation (DNAm) in human social and emotional functioning: a systematic narrative review

Background

The neuropeptide Oxytocin (OXT) plays a central role in birthing, mother-infant bonding and a broad range of related social behaviours in mammals. More recently, interest has extended to epigenetic programming of genes involved in oxytocinergic neurotransmission. This review brings together early findings in a rapidly developing field of research, examining relationships between DNA methylation (DNAm) of the Oxytocin Receptor Gene (OXTR) and social and emotional behaviour in human populations.

Method

A systematic search across Web of Knowledge/Science, Scopus, Medline and EMBASE captured all published studies prior to June 2017 examining the association between OXTR DNAm and human social and emotional outcomes. Search terms included ‘oxytocin gene’ or ‘oxytocin receptor gene’ and ‘epigenetics’ or ‘DNA methylation’. Any article with a focus on social and emotional functioning was then identified from this set by manual review.

Results

Nineteen studies met eligibility criteria. There was considerable heterogeneity of study populations, tissue samples, instrumentation, measurement, and OXTR site foci. Only three studies examined functional consequences of OXTR DNAm on gene expression and protein synthesis. Increases in OXTR DNAm were associated with callous-unemotional traits in youth, social cognitive deficits in Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD), rigid thinking in anorexia nervosa, affect regulation problems, and problems with facial and emotional recognition. In contrast, reductions in DNAm were associated with perinatal stress, postnatal depression, social anxiety and autism in children.

Conclusions

Consistent with an emerging field of inquiry, there is not yet sufficient evidence to draw conclusions about the role of OXTR DNAm in human social and emotional behaviour. However, taken together, findings point to increased OXTR DNAm in general impairments in social, cognitive and emotional functioning, and decreased OXTR DNAm in specific patterns of impairment related to mood and anxiety disorders (but not in all). Future progress in this field would be enhanced by adequately powered designs, greater phenotypic precision, and methodological improvements including longitudinal studies with multiple time-points to facilitate causal inference.

Oxytocin (OXT) is a neuropeptide and hormone implicated in prosocial human social and emotional functioning [1]. OXT has been long known for its key role in child birth and postpartum lactation, including changes in infant gut hormones [2]. OXT plays a crucial role in enhancing bonding and moderating the stress response. Mothers’ neuroendocrine response to their baby’s cry, as measured by functional neuroimaging (fMRI), has shown to differ between vaginal and caesarean births, with higher OXT levels linked to enhanced empathy and maternal arousal [3]. Mothers with higher plasma OXT levels during early pregnancy have been shown to be more responsive to their baby after birth, including higher levels of gaze towards their infant’s face, positive affect and affectionate touch [4].

Postpartum, the sucking stimulus by newborns increases OXT release in the mother and thus decreases plasma levels of stress hormones (ACTH and cortisol) [5]. The physiological consequences of disrupted OXT release are thus significant during the perinatal period, however, there is also mounting evidence that disrupted OXT availability could be related to a broad range of social behaviours, including childhood autistic spectrum disorders (ASD) [6], attachment bonds in infancy [7] and mood disorders and response to stress in women [8].

This has led to the development of OXT treatments including using nasal OXT to increase attachment security in healthy males with an insecure attachment pattern [9] and improved social engagement between fathers and their infants [10]. Further, intranasal OXT increased trust and willingness to accept social risks amongst healthy volunteers involved in an experimental game [11], as well as the reduction of the short-term stress response demonstrated by reduced cortisol release [12]. In patients with Autistic spectrum disorder (ASD), intranasal OXT has been shown to provide some improvements in adult social cognition [6] and youth emotional recognition [13].

fMRI studies have shown that during a visual stress task, intranasal OXT administration is associated with reduced activation in the amygdala, which plays a key role in emotion and social behaviour regulation [14]. Furthermore, central OXT has both anxiolytic and antidepressant effects which have been associated with improved emotional behaviours and mental health [15]. This has led to the suggestion that OXT may be an important biomarker of stress exposures [16]. OXT plasma concentrations also correlate with cerebrospinal concentrations and with childhood anxiety [17]. Disrupted peripheral OXT release has been found in non-perinatal women with depression during stress related tasks [8] and with specific types of relationship stress in women [18]. Taken together, these findings suggest an important role for OXT in human social and emotional functioning.

Neurobiologically, OXT is synthesized by the OXT gene in magnocellular neurons in the paraventricular and supraoptic nuclei of the hypothalamus. OXT is then transported along axonal projections to the posterior lobe of the pituitary, where it is stored in secretory vesicles before being released into the peripheral blood. In addition, dendritic release of OXT occurs into the extracellular space with diffusion through the brain. Smaller parvocellular neurons in the paraventricular nucleus also produce OXT and project directly to other regions in the brain involved in human social and emotional functioning including the amygdala, hippocampus, striatum, suprachiasmatic nucleus, bed nucleus of stria terminalis and brainstem - where they act as neuromodulators or neurotransmitters and thereby influence neurotransmission in these areas [19].

Oxytocin receptors are synthesised by the Oxytocin Receptor (OXTR) gene, which expresses both centrally in the brain and within peripheral organs. In this way, OXT has both peripheral and central functions. OXTR is located on human chromosome 3p25.3 [20, 21]. The OXTR gene spans 17 kilobytes (kb) and contains 3 introns and 4 exons. Exons 1 and 2 correspond to non-coding regions while exons 3 and 4 encode the amino acids of the oxytocin receptor (Fig. 2). The oxytocin receptor is a 389-amino acid G-protein coupled transmembrane receptor, enabling the activation of a number of different intracellular secondary messengers facilitating the oxytocin pathway [22].

Genetic variants, including single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), in the OXTR have been shown to independently influence gene expression and been associated with human emotional responsiveness and social behaviour [23]. Two SNPs rs2254298 and rs53576 have been most investigated regarding the OXTR (Intron 3) (Fig. 2). Rs2254298 (G > A) has also been associated with autistic spectrum disorder (ASD) [24], depressed women and their families [25] and with smaller bilateral amygdala volumes and greater grey matter volumes in a brain imaging study [26], while rs237887 has been associated with human social recognition skills [27]. Rs53576 (A > G) has been associated with reduced positivity [28], reduced empathy [29] and decreased parental sensitivity [30] while rs1042778 has been associated with reduced parenting sensitivity [31] and rs237915 has been associated with brain responsiveness to social cues [32]. A meta-analysis of 11 independent populations of patients with ASD reported associations with rs7632287, rs237887, rs2268491 and rs2254298 [33].

The focus of this review is on the newly emerging field of OXTR epigenetics and socio-emotional functioning in humans. Epigenetic mechanisms are reversible modifications occurring “above” the level of the DNA sequence, which can influence gene expression [34]. The most widely investigated and understood epigenetic mechanism is DNA methylation (DNAm), which commonly involves the addition of methyl groups to the cytosine and guanine dinucleotides termed “CpG” dinucleotides in the DNA sequence. OXTR is of particular interest because, unlike OXT, which has tight regional expression, OXTR is expressed extensively through brain and body and can thus control the final (rate-limiting) step in signal transmission. Differential methylation of the OXTR has been associated with changes in OXTR expression both in animals and in humans.

In mouse models, OXTR DNAm patterns have been correlated with differential OXTR expression in different body tissues [35]. In different brain areas, differing DNAm at specific CpG regions within the OXTR occurred with differential expression of OXTR [36]. The differential OXTR expression is considered to relate to a diversity of animal social behaviours arising from the limbic brain structures. Though animal and human OXTR gene promoter brain regions differ, the inference is that DNAm differences result in OXTR transcription changes with impact on human social and emotional behaviour.

In human samples, a region within the OXTR third intron between regions encoding trans-membrane domains 6 and 7, has been shown to be hyper-methylated within non-expressing tissues, but hypo-methylated in the uterine myometrium at term, when OXT is up-regulated for the birthing process [21]. Further work on OXTR has identified a region between the first exon and the first intron (MT2 segment) that is linked to tissue specific expression OXTR in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), liver, and uterine myometrium (from non-pregnant and term-pregnancies) [37]. Genetic variation may also influence patterns of DNAm within the gene [38,39,40,41] and thus can have both combined and independent effects on gene expression [42, 43]. However, lack of replication to date requires cautious interpretation.

The purpose of this review by narrative synthesis is to bring together the emerging evidence on OXTR DNAm and human socio-emotional functioning. The diversity of studies available in this new area of research currently precludes meta-analytic presentation of findings. This review provides a timely summary of a new field of research around OXTR and socio-emotional behaviour, with implications for future promotion of emotional health in both population and clinical settings.

A review of the literature was undertaken to identify all published studies that investigated oxytocin receptor gene (OXTR) DNAm in human social behaviour, with a focus on social and/or emotional functioning. We defined human social and emotional functioning as the experience, expression and management of emotions as well as the ability to establish positive and rewarding relationships with others [44]. This extends to relationships, response to stress and social cognition with a basis in neurobiology, which has become more available to research through functional brain scanning.

Search strategy and inclusion criteria

Included studies were identified using review methodology, conducted across four primary search database platforms: Web of Knowledge/Science, Scopus, Medline and EMBASE and included papers through to May 2017. The search terms used were: ‘oxytocin gene’ or ‘oxytocin receptor gene’ and ‘epigenetics’ or ‘DNA methylation’ and limited to studies involving humans and those written in English. Four different searches were completed with each search using terms: ‘oxytocin gene’ or oxytocin ‘receptor gene’ and one of ‘epigenetics’ or ‘DNA methylation’. These four different term search strategies were repeated from October 2013 to May 2017 on three separate occasions. This allowed for identification of new research as well as the confirmation of those articles already located. There were no exclusions based on participant age or study design. Studies which measured OXTR DNAm in the context of oncology, pregnancy or lactation were also excluded. The search was not restricted to specific psychosocial terms; rather, articles with a focus on emotional and social functioning were identified by manual review from the full set meeting criteria for epigenetic search terms. Manual identification of studies was also employed by examining the reference lists of original research articles retrieved, as well as reviews published in this area. No new articles were identified by this latter method that had not already been retrieved from the original designated term searches.

From all studies identified through the initial search, titles and abstracts were examined to determine their suitability for inclusion in the review. Titles often identified the article related to non-human studies, focused on oncology/obstetrics, related to oxytocin or not to epigenetics. When uncertainty occurred, further investigation of the abstract clarified the exact contact of the article. Studies included were original research articles investigating epigenetic regulation of OXTR and its association with social or emotional behaviours in humans, including social perception, mood problems (depression and stress), behaviour problems (eating disorder and callousness) and rarer neurodevelopment disorders (autism). No epigenetic studies were found where mechanisms other than DNAm were considered.

Figure 1 presents a PRISMA flow diagram showing initial study identification and stepwise exclusions of ineligible studies. A total 374 articles were initially identified for review. Of these a total of 19 were eligible for inclusion in the final review. Details of each are provided in Table 1. Study populations varied widely in age, heritage and from general population to clinical samples. Sample sizes were variable and predominantly small though size has been increasing in more recent research [45]. Most studies focused on the “MT2 segment” (between Exon 1 and Intron 1), the region identified as functionally significant in the initial gene expression studies (Fig. 2, Area A) [21, 37, 46]. Increased DNAm of this region, including the site − 934, has been linked to decreased OXTR gene transcription in both PBMCs and brain [46]. No study has examined the extent to which DNAm influences gene expression in Exon 3, (Fig. 2, Area B).

PRISMA Flow Diagram

Full size image

Oxytocin Receptor Gene (OXTR Chr:3 p25)

Full size image

Only one of the 19 studies directly examined the relationship between OXTR DNAm and gene expression [46]. Two studies investigated a possible association between DNAm changes at the OXTR and subsequent oxytocin neuropeptide synthesis [47, 48]. As DNAm marks can be cell and tissue specific, it is important to note that most studies have used DNA derived from blood samples. One study each used buccal [49] and saliva samples [38], the latter of which may contain buccal epithelium and blood cells, including peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs). A third study investigated a small subset of brain tissue collected post-mortem [46].

Social perception

Jack et al. [50] and Puglia et al. [51] examined the association between OXTR DNAm and brain activation using fMRI brain scanning while participants completed social perception tasks. The first involved visual animation tasks with different social perceptions [50], while the second used emotional face-matching tasks [47]. Both studies involved healthy young adults and examined OXTR DNAm in PBMCs, focusing on only one specific CpG site (− 934), around the MT2 segment. In both studies, results showed DNAm to be positively associated with brain activity in specific regions. These included the temporal parietal junction and dorsal anterior cingulate brain areas, regions associated with the face, the amygdala and fusiform gyrus and insula involved in emotion processing. Increased DNAm was also associated with decreased connectivity between the neural systems supporting social perception and decreased functional coupling of the amygdala within regions associated with affect appraisal and emotional regulation.

Social stress

Unternaehrer et al. [52] examined the possibility of dynamically changing levels of DNA methylation in response to a social stress test within a longitudinal study design. DNAm at two proximal regions of the OXTR promoter was measured in whole venous blood over a 90-min interval, in 75 older individuals. In one of the regions, an increase in DNAm at the majority of CpG sites was found from pre-test to 10 min post-test. At both OXTR regions DNAm decreased between 10 min post-test and 90 min follow-up. The effect sizes observed were small but significant. The investigators completed cell counts and controlled for these differences in their analysis, also acknowledging that changes in dynamic cell composition could contribute to their results.

Anxiety disorders

Two studies examining OXTR DNAm in the exon 3 region from blood and anxiety disorders were identified [53, 54]. Ziegler et al., investigated 110 adults with social anxiety compared to 110 healthy controls and noted reduced DNAm at only one of twelve CpG OXTR exon 3 sites on psychological, cortisol response and fMRI measures [54]. When average DNAm was considered across all twelve CpG sites, reduced methylation was also observed compared to controls. No difference between socially anxious patients and controls was noted when the rs53576 genotype was investigated. Furthermore, Cappi et al., studied 73 adults with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) compared to 31 healthy controls and found increased DNAm at two of nine CpG OXTR sites in OCD adults compared to controls [53]. DNAm was positively correlated with OCD severity. In contrast, an inverse correlation was found between DNAm at eight of the nine sites for depressive scores in OCD adults. This could suggest that social anxiety and OCD sit on different dimensions, as is now the case in the latest iteration of the DSM-5 in which OCD is considered to be related to ASD and rigidity of thinking where as social anxiety disorder is considered a form of mood disorder.

Depression

Reiner et al. compared OXTR DNAm in PBMCs between depressed pre-menopausal women and non-depressed age-matched controls [40]. Three fragments across exons 1 and 2 of OXTR (A, B and C) were measured. A decrease in DNAm of the exon 1 fragment A, (Fig. 2) was observed in depressed compared to non-depressed women. A specific OXTR SNP rs53576 with a G to A allele change, known to be associated with reduced pro-sociality and decreased empathy, was also investigated [29]. This SNP moderated the association between DNAm of exon 1 and depression status and was found to be independently associated with exon 2 methylation levels. Depressed individuals with the A allele had increased mean DNAm compared to those homozygous for the G allele but healthy controls had the opposite result [40].

A further study by Chagnon et al. compared 19 depressed older women (all but one of whom also had anxiety) with 24 controls both in terms of saliva DNAm, average methylation across exon 3, and with regard to rs53576 [38]. There were no differences in overall DNAm between groups; however, depressed women homozygous for the A allele of rs53576 showed a significant increase in DNAm compared to controls. Different genotypes may have an independent impact on DNAm, which could contribute to these differing results [23]. The age of the population, including physiological states such as weight loss, hormonal and mood influences and the independent effect of the genotype itself may variously account for the different results.

Perinatal disorders

Unternaehrer et al. also investigated OXTR DNAm in the cord blood of 39 infants born to mothers who had completed psychological testing and saliva cortisol testing during the second and third trimesters of their pregnancies [55]. Cord blood is the first available tissue following birth, which allows for the exclusion of postnatal factors impacting on the DNAm process. In their final testing 7 OXTR CpG units, including 13 sites, were investigated for DNAm with varying results. Reduced DNAm in the cord blood of the infants was associated with the total number of stressful life events in the two years prior to the second trimester, but not the strain caused by these events. Likewise, reduced DNAm in infant cord blood was associated with maternal depressive symptoms in the second trimester and certain elevated salivary cortisol level measurements from the second and third trimesters. The investigators used specific mixed modelling and batch effects analysis to obtain more reliable results.

Using data from the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC), Bell et al. measured OXTR DNAm in whole blood, as well as two OXTR SNPs rs53576 and rs2254298 and investigated associations with perinatal depressive symptoms [39]. While no main effects were observed, overall a significant DNAm by genotype interaction was associated with the risk of postnatal depression. For women who were rs53576 GG homozygous alleles, there was a positive correlation between OXTR DNAm and depressive symptoms postpartum. This finding is in contrast to the other studies of depression where associations were found between OXTR DNAm and depression risk for individuals with the rs53576 A allele [38, 40], possibly accounted for by hormonal differences compared to mood disorders at differing times in the life-cycle.

Additionally, Kimmel et al., investigated 51 women with postnatal depression considering the complex hormonal impact, including estradiol on OXTR methylation [56]. Though 18 OXTR loci were investigated, only one demonstrated significantly decreased DNAm in the whole blood samples of the cohort and no significant rs53576 analysis was noted.

Maternal care

In a sample of 85 university students, Unternaehrer et al. compared OXTR DNAm across groups who retrospectively reported low or high maternal care [57]. No SNP genotypes were examined. Students reporting a history of low maternal care had increased DNAm at one of 23 CpG units examined. In addition to the retrospective self-reporting of early maternal care, confounding from other factors is an obvious limitation given the large time gap between childhood and the period when DNAm was measured. Smearman et al. likewise examined association between OXTR and retrospective reporting of childhood abuse and adult psychiatric symptoms (anxiety and depression) [41]. This study, with 393 African American participants, involved a comprehensive investigation of 18 CpG sites across the OXTR gene, as well as 44 OXTR SNPs. Of the 44 SNPs examined, 68% were associated with proximal DNAm levels. Non-significant trends were observed between childhood abuse and higher DNAm at two CpG sites in exon 3, as well as an interaction between childhood abuse and DNAm to predict adult psychopathology. Six SNPs of interest were also shown to interact with childhood abuse in determining risk for psychiatric symptoms, independently of DNAm levels.

Anorexia nervosa

Kim et al. studied Korean patients with Anorexia Nervosa and investigated DNAm of the OXTR MT2 region in buccal samples [49]. They found increased DNAm in 15 clinical patients compared to 36 University recruited controls. The extent of DNAm negatively correlated with illness severity (BMI) and eating disorder psychopathology. As no longitudinal analysis was undertaken, the temporal relationship between increased DNAm and onset of Anorexia Nervosa could not be established. It remains unclear whether changes in OXTR DNAm patterns precede or are the consequence of the disease.

Callous unemotional

Two studies measured peripheral blood OXTR DNAm in children and adolescents with conduct problems, with a particular focus on Callous Unemotional (CU) traits [47, 58]. As part of the ALSPAC study, Cecil and colleagues measured OXTR DNAm at birth in a subset of 84 boys and girls and found a positive association with CU traits in later childhood (7–9 years) [58]. There was no difference in association when the groups were stratified by internalising problems. In contrast, Dadds et al. focused on males only (n = 98) and found no association between OXTR promoter DNAm and CU traits overall, but some evidence that increased DNAm levels at one particular CpG site were associated with increased CU traits in older youth (aged 9–16 years) [47]. In a small subset of this cohort (n = 37), authors reported increased DNAm and lower oxytocin protein levels in the blood of older children (aged 9–16 years) but caution against over interpretation due to power limitations. Additionally, 9 OXTR SNPs were examined. Only rs1042778 replicated an association with high CU traits across sexes and between childhood versus adolescent age groups within 2 separated geographical groups [59].

Autism Spectrum disorder

While numerous studies have investigated the role of OXTR genetic variations in ASD, only three to date have examined OXTR DNAm [45, 46, 60]. The first study by Gregory et al., reported findings from three separate analyses [46]. The first included screening of 119 ASD pro-bands and their families to identify DNAm differences at OXTR sites in PBMCs, focusing on the area in the promoter region around the MT2 site. Increased DNAm was noted in ASD pro-bands compared to healthy family members. This analysis was complemented by a small ASD case-control study (n = 40) focusing on the same OXTR sites identified in their initial analysis demonstrating similar results. The authors also used eight samples from a brain bank of patients with autism and eight controls and compared DNAm levels in PBMCs with these brain temporal cortical samples, finding both had increased DNAm. This group further examined brain OXTR DNAm with gene expression in samples of temporal cortex from 4 ASD pro-bands (3 males and 1 female), matched with controls. For the 3 males only, OXTR expression was reduced by 20% compared to controls. Results from these studies suggest remarkable consistency across the different tissues (PBMCs and brain temporal cortex). They support a relationship between increased DNAm and decreased OXTR gene expression, with the suggestion that there may be sex-specific effects (findings in males and not female, in a small cohort).

A second study by Elagoz Yuksel et al., found the opposite effect in children with ASD, with decreased DNAm in two of four areas of the OXTR including MT1 (exon 1) and MT3 (intron 1, exon 2 and intron 2) when peripheral blood samples of 27 children with ASD were compared to 39 healthy controls [60]. Both ASD and healthy control children were predominantly male. It is important to note that these investigators did not find any significant associations within the MT2 area, which had been previously been implicated by Gregory et al. [46] and Kusui et al. [37].

A third study by Rijlaarsdam et al., investigated OXTR DNAm associated with the specific SNP rs 53,576 in cord blood sampled at birth from children later diagnosed with autistic traits at six years’ of age [45]. Increased DNAm was found in those children with rs53576 G-allele homozygous who demonstrated higher social problem scores. Prenatal maternal stress exposure was also investigated but not found to be associated with OXTR DNAm in this sample of children.

Psychotic disorders

Rubin et al., investigated the whole blood samples of 167 patients with both affective and non-affective psychoses compared to 75 healthy controls [48]. A further component of this study was fMRI of a subsample of this cohort during a facial emotional recognition test. OXTR DNAm was examined in one specific CpG site (− 934), around MT2 segment, similar to studies by Jack et al. [50] and Puglia et al. [51]. Findings point to increased DNAm when patients with non-affective psychosis were compared to those with affective psychosis. Gender specific effects were noted with increased DNAm in females with psychosis compared with males, increased DNAm associated with poorer emotional recognition in females and controls than males, and increased DNAm associated with smaller brain volumes in areas related to social cognition (temporal-limbic and pre-frontal regions) in females with non-affective psychosis and healthy control females. This study also measured oxytocin protein levels but found no significant association with these and OXTR DNAm in the psychotic or control group unlike the study by Dadd et al., when investigating callous unemotional children [47]. Gender differences were noted when plasma oxytocin levels and DNAm were investigated with a negative association for males (p = 0.04) and a positive association for females (p = 0.03).

The role of OXTR DNAm in human social and emotional functioning is a relatively new area of investigation. There are currently few studies in the field and methods and findings are highly variable, precluding firm conclusions about the role of OXTR DNAm. However, within this context, several non-replicated associations between OXTR DNAm and outcomes in various domains are emerging in the literature. These include positive associations between OXTR DNAm and callous-unemotional traits in youth [47, 58], social cognitive deficits in ASD [45, 46], rigid thinking in anorexia nervosa [49], affect regulation problems [41, 57] and mood deficits [38,39,40] as well as limbic regions linked with facial and emotional recognition [48, 50, 51]. In contrast, reduced OXTR DNAm has been associated within indicators of perinatal stress [55], postnatal depression [56], social anxiety [53] and autism in children [60].

Taken together, findings suggest a role for increased OXTR DNAm (which may indicate reduced receptor expression) in general impairments in social, cognitive and emotional functioning, and decreased OXTR DNAm (which may indicate increased receptor expression) in specific patterns of impairment related to mood and anxiety disorders (but not all). However, patterns of association both within and across outcomes are difficult to clearly demarcate, and most likely reflect the broad range of differences that exist between studies at this early point in the development of the field. For example, reported associations for mood disorders are in both direction, which may reflect striking differences between studies, including type of mood disorder under investigation, epigenome regions studied, underlying variation in genotypic and hormonal factors [39, 56] as well as the effect of aging [38].

Furthermore, exceedingly little is known about the functional implications of OXTR DNAm in humans. Only one study has reported a relationship between increased OXTR DNAm and reduced OXTR expression [46]. Another has reported a relationship between mean OXTR DNAm across eleven probes (spanning exon 1 to intron 1) and circulating oxytocin protein levels; however, this was not replicated in another study examining a single CpG site (− 934) in intron 1 [48]. This is an important area for future research. Genetic association findings are equally non-conclusive with results differing considerably across the studies. Lack of reproducibility is common in genetic association studies and likely reflects small sample sizes of unknown representation with underpowering. Future progress on genetic influences will depend on access to larger samples and benefit by a shift from its current focus on candidate SNPs to genome-wide analysis (GWAS). Furthermore, replication opportunities are essential for establishing the credibility of reported genetic associations. Earliest canvassing of these opportunities would permit optimised alignment of research samples and instrumentation.

A further driver of heterogeneity of DNAm findings is choice of tissue for analysis. Studies in humans are limited to peripheral tissue collections i.e. buccal, blood or saliva. The common embryological origin of brain and buccal cells suggests that these two cell types may have more in common than blood cells, and that using buccal cells as a peripheral biomarker might provide a closer approximation to central brain processes, relative to other cell types [61]. At minimum, the tissue specific nature of many epigenetic processes is likely to be an important contributing factor. The different methods of analysis of OXTR DNAm from individual probe methylation to EWAS analysis reflect the challenges of cost, in a new area of investigation which further complicate result comparisons.

From a statistical methods perspective, the majority of studies have investigated methylation at numerous individual CpG sites [38, 40, 41, 45, 46, 49, 52,53,54,55, 57, 58], but only a few studies have considered adjustment for multiple comparisons in their analysis, [41, 47,48,49, 53, 55, 56], to reduce the risk of false positive findings (type 1 errors). This is particularly problematic for studies which have investigated a large number of gene regions and CpG sites. It thus remains possible that at least some of the findings shown here are chance associations, and replication in an independent sample is crucial. On the other hand, some of the studies have used factor analysis to reduce the number of CpG sites and thus tests [40, 45, 47, 58]. The downside of these studies is that factor analysis is a data driven process and does not necessarily make biological sense. Further, conclusions cannot be drawn about the impact of DNA methylation at individual CpGs.

Longitudinal cohort studies beginning in the perinatal period provide the optimal opportunity to study humans at crucial time points during life. This informs knowledge as to how epigenetics contributes to the changing phenotype. Ng et al. identified that in thirty-four life course studies related to the epigenetic mechanism of DNAm, only four studies included information taken from more than 1-time point. Of these four, one study involved epigenetic changes over a relatively short time period (28–180 days) [62]. The Avon Longitudinal study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC) has collected serial samples across the life-span from individual participants providing the gold standard in longitudinal cohort studies for epigenetic analysis [63]. Longitudinal studies which collect biomarkers, at multiple time-points, starting in the perinatal period for epigenetic investigation are unique as an assessment of the changing life-course phenotype. Cross-sectional analyses of epigenetic data lack utility in attempting to understand developmental change or causation direction in epigenetic epidemiology [64].

This narrative literature review examines findings from nineteen papers, which have investigated OXTR DNAm associated with social and emotional functioning in humans. The broad and heterogeneous nature of these studies preclude definitive conclusions. This is typical of a new field of research where the study diversity in design, methodology, phenotype and outcome make meaningful conclusions challenging.

Despite these considerable limitations, emerging evidence points to increased OXTR DNAm in general impairments of social, cognitive and emotional functioning, and decreased OXTR DNAm in specific patterns of impairment related to mood and anxiety disorders (but not in all). These higher-level patterns are speculative at best in this stage of the field’s early development. The essential “next step” is to establish with greater certainty the functional relationship between OXTR DNAm and actual OXTR gene expression. Related to this is greater clarity about potential differences in OXTR DNAm across peripheral tissues currently collected in human studies in relation to central brain tissue OXTR processes. If these fundamentals can be established, progress would be facilitated by increased homogeneity in study design, including phenotypic definition and measurement. This includes greater investment in high quality measurement, such as micro-coding of social interaction using gold-standard protocols, for example, human attachment behaviour, within observational designs [65]. Future progress would also be enhanced by greater investment in embedded DNAm studies within longitudinal designs that enable temporal ordering of relationships with biological collections at multiple time-points. The Developmental Origins of Health and Disease (DOHaD) paradigm emphasises the centrality of exposures within the first 1000 days from conception, however sensitive periods may occur both before and after birth [66]. Longitudinal cohort studies, particularly those with mature cohorts that cross more than one generation, will provide important future opportunities for investigating change over time. Of particular interest are longstanding cohorts prospectively tracking offspring development, given their unique opportunity to explore effects beyond a single generation, to those that transmit to subsequent generations.

ADI-R:

Autism Diagnostic Interview-revised

ALSPAC:

Avon Longitudinal study of parents & children

AQ:

Autism-Spectrum Quotient

ASD:

Autistic Spectrum Disorder

AUCg:

Area under curve with respect to ground

BAI:

Beck Anxiety Inventory

BDI:

Beck Depression Inventory

BMI:

Body Mass Index

BSI:

Brief Symptom Inventory

CARS:

Childhood Autism Rating Scale

CBCL:

Child Behaviour Checklist

CBT:

Cognitive Behavioural therapy

CpG island:

Cytosine phosphate Guanine dinucleotide island

CTQ:

Childhood trauma questionnaire

CU:

Callous Unemotional traits

dACC:

Dorsal anterior cingulate cortex

DOHaD:

Developmental Origins of Health and Disease

DSM IV:

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth Edition

DSM IV-TR:

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth Edition text revision

EDE-Q:

Eating Disorders Examination-Questionnaire

EDPS:

Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale

ESME:

Epigenetic Sequencing Methylation analysis software

EWAS:

Epigenome Wide Association Studies

fMRI:

Functional magnetic resonance imaging

GWAS:

Genome Wide Association Studies

HAMA:

Hamilton Anxiety Scale

ILE:

Inventory of Life Events

IQ:

Intelligence

kb:

kilobytes

MDD:

Major Depressive Disorder

MMSE:

Mini Mental State Examination to screen for cognitive impairments

OCD:

Obsessive Compulsive Disorder

OXT:

Oxytocin

OXTR:

Oxytocin receptor gene

PBI:

Parental Bonding Instrument

PDP:

Pervasive behaviour checklist

PMCS:

Peripheral mononuclear cells in venous blood

SCID:

Structured Clinical Interview from DSM IV

SIAS:

Social Interaction Anxiety Scale

SNPs:

Single nucleotide polymorphisms

SPS:

Social Phobia Scale

SRS:

Social Responsiveness Scale

STAI:

Spielberger State and Trait Anxiety Inventory

TICS-K:

Trier Inventory of Chronic Stress – short version

TSST:

Trier Social Stress test

Y-BOCS:

Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale

YGTTS:

Yale Global Tic Severity Scale

The authors would like to thank the team members of the Australian Temperament Project (ATP), Murdoch Research Institute, Melbourne, Australia for providing ongoing feedback and support.

Availability of data and materials

The data that supports these findings (the studies reviewed in this study) are available via their published journals; the summaries of these nineteen studies are included within Table 1, in this article.

Affiliations

1. Deakin University Geelong, Centre for Social and Early Emotional Development, Faculty of Health, School of Psychology, 221 Burwood Highway, Burwood, VIC, 3125, Australia
   • Catherine Maud
   • , Jennifer E. McIntosh
   •  & Craig A. Olsson
2. Murdoch Children’s Research Institute, The Royal Children’s Hospital, Parkville, VIC, 3052, Australia
   • Joanne Ryan
   • , Jennifer E. McIntosh
   •  & Craig A. Olsson
3. Department of Paediatrics, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC, 3052, Australia
   • Joanne Ryan
   •  & Craig A. Olsson
4. Department of Epidemiology and Preventative Medicine, School of Public Health and Preventative Medicine, Monash University, Prahran, VIC, 3004, Australia
   • Joanne Ryan

Contributions

All authors developed the core concept of this review article. CM devised the research strategy and conducted the search with guidance from JR and CO. CM primarily wrote the manuscript with all authors revising the intellectual content. All authors have given final approval for the publication.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Catherine Maud.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Reprints and Permissions